Blog

Custody battles involve tough choices. Many fathers involved in custody litigation will ask, “Can children express preference in a Lafayette custody proceeding?” Louisiana courts address this question with clear guidelines. When deciding custody, there are legal standards, judicial practices, and other circumstances that influence how much a child’s voice impacts a custody decision.

When Louisiana Courts Consider a Child’s Preference

The child’s preference is only one of 14 factors a Judge will consider in determining custody.  Judges review whether the child is mature enough to make an informed choice and whether the child is being influenced in any way. A preference expressed by a younger child carries less weight than one articulated by a teenager if they have clear reasoning.

Judges evaluate whether the child’s preference aligns with what would be in their best interest. Parental stability, safety, and the parent’s ability to meet their child’s needs are considered alongside and in conjunction with the child’s wishes. Courts consider the 14 factors of Louisiana Civil Code article 134 in making a determination of the child’s best interest, as follows:

(1) The potential for the child to be abused, as defined by Children’s Code Article 603, which shall be the primary consideration.

(2) The love, affection, and other emotional ties between each party and the child.

(3) The capacity and disposition of each party to give the child love, affection, and spiritual guidance and to continue the education and rearing of the child.

(4) The capacity and disposition of each party to provide the child with food, clothing, medical care, and other material needs.

(5) The length of time the child has lived in a stable, adequate environment, and the desirability of maintaining continuity of that environment.

(6) The permanence, as a family unit, of the existing or proposed custodial home or homes.

(7) The moral fitness of each party, insofar as it affects the welfare of the child.

(8) The history of substance abuse, violence, or criminal activity of any party.

(9) The mental and physical health of each party. Evidence that an abused parent suffers from the effects of past abuse by the other parent shall not be grounds for denying that parent custody.

(10) The home, school, and community history of the child.

(11) The reasonable preference of the child if the court deems the child to be of sufficient age to express a preference.

(12) The willingness and ability of each party to facilitate and encourage a close and continuing relationship between the child and the other party, except when objectively substantial evidence of specific abusive, reckless, or illegal conduct has caused one party to have reasonable concerns for the child’s safety or well-being while in the care of the other party.

(13) The distance between the respective residences of the parties.

(14) The responsibility for the care and rearing of the child previously exercised by each party.

The context of the preference also matters. A court questions the motives of choices made due to pressure, manipulation, or conflict. To reduce the risks of children making decisions out of stress, judges rely on professionals and assessments to avoid placing emotional burdens on children.

Limits on a Child’s Preference

Judges consider multiple factors to evaluate whether to consider a child’s preference, including:

• Maturity and Understanding: A preference holds less weight if the child lacks the maturity to understand long-term consequences. Judges assess whether reasoning reflects thoughtful consideration and if the child can understand these issues.
• Parental Fitness: Courts prioritize the ability of each parent to provide a safe and nurturing environment. A preference favoring a parent who’s unfit for a child carries little significance to a judge.
• Stability and Practical Concerns: Factors like school continuity, distance to extended family, and logistical issues may be considered. Courts aim for solutions that promote long-term stability.
• Safety Concerns: Preferences that don’t align with the child’s physical or emotional safety are disregarded. Judges prioritize protecting the child from harm, even against their expressed desires.

Judges investigate the context of the child’s choice to make sure they make a fair decision.

Useful Advice for Louisiana Parents

Parents should prioritize creating an environment wherein their kids feel safe expressing their true feelings and preferences. This means avoiding pressure or influence that sways a child’s statements or choices. By keeping a neutral space, parents help preserve trust and reduce the emotional impact of custody discussions.

The child’s best interest is at the forefront of all custody decisions. Parents have to prioritize stable routines and support their child’s emotional health throughout the process. Personal preferences might be strong, but focusing on what truly benefits the child leads to more positive long-term outcomes for everyone.

Professional support may assist in determining custody. Engaging qualified consultants, like counselors or mediators, can provide objective perspectives and assessments of the situation. These professionals have the experience needed to identify and understand a child’s needs and preferences to help parents make informed decisions and may assist the court in rendering a decision.

Effective communication between parents affects custody results. When parents can communicate respectfully and cooperatively, they can reach agreements that reflect the needs of their children. A collaborative strategy leads to more sustainable custody arrangements that benefit parents and children.

Why Do I Need an Attorney?

Working with an experienced family law attorney can help your case stay compliant with Louisiana’s custody standards. Professional legal support helps fathers advocate for fairness and their children’s well-being. A lawyer’s guidance is especially valuable in maneuvering through court proceedings, especially when addressing complicated custody issues or experiencing challenging circumstances.

An attorney can clarify difficult laws and help families follow required procedures. Proper representation also reduces mistakes that could threaten custody arrangements. By professionally addressing issues, a Lafayette child custody lawyer can keep you from making emotionally charged decisions.

If your case goes to court, an attorney can emphasize factors that support your rights as a parent. They can show you how to best highlight your involvement in the child’s education, healthcare, and daily activities to show stability and commitment.

FAQs

Q: At What Age Can a Child’s Preference Be Considered in a Lafayette Custody Case?

A: The age at which a child’s preference can be considered in a Lafayette custody case varies based on the child’s maturity and understanding. Instead of assigning a strict age threshold, judges assess whether a child can articulate reasons for a preference and understand the consequences of their decision. Maturity, emotional stability, and context all influence whether a court factors in the child’s wishes.

Q: How Does a Judge Review a Child’s Input During a Custody Hearing?

A: A judge may not only review a child’s input during a custody hearing, but also use interviews or reports from guardians, counselors, or other professionals to obtain an objective viewpoint and determine the sincerity and soundness of the child’s reasoning. The court will also review other factors, such as any influence from other sources, like parents or other family members, as well as whether their choice aligns with the child’s best interests.

Q: Are There Limits to How Much a Child’s Preference Impacts Custody?

A: A child’s preference is only one of fourteen factors enumerated in La. Civil Code article 134 that Judges consider. A child’s wishes hold less weight if the preference comes from pressure, manipulation, or a lack of understanding of the situation. There are also sometimes safety concerns or logistical issues that can conflict with a child’s preferences.

Q: Can a Child Testify in a Lafayette Custody Proceeding?

A: A minor child may testify in custody proceedings; however, certain accommodations are often made to reduce the stress upon the child and disruptions to family relationships. If a child’s testimony is important, judges use private interviews or feedback from third-party professionals to understand the child’s perspective. Safeguards are in place to reduce harm to children and promote accurate and unbiased information.

Strengthen Your Strategy with a Lafayette Child Custody Lawyer by Your Side

Fathers have the right to know how custody laws affect their case. Child custody laws provide a structured approach to considering a child’s preference during a divorce or custody battle, considering factors like age, emotional bonds, and family details. To learn more, schedule a consultation with Laura L. Davenport, LLC, today to guide your family toward practical and fair solutions.